SAYING WHAT HAS TO BE SAID...IN TRUE LIBERTARIAN FASHION
This year we have heard with increasing regularity, outrage expressed by Christian and non-Christian alike over the issue of Christmas. Many Christian groups are appalled by efforts on the part of some local governments and retailers to refer to the season as the “Holiday Season” or “Winter Break,” as if that wasn’t bad enough, the furor over calling trees “Holiday Trees,” rather than “Christmas Trees” has sparked even greater outrage. Some groups have called for boycotts of retailers that refer to this period as the “Holiday Season,” or wish people “Happy Holidays,” rather than “Merry Christmas.” So is this much ado about nothing? Yes and no is the not so simple answer. Christians celebrate December 25th (January 7th for Orthodox Christians) as the birth of Christ Jesus, in fulfillment of prophecy. It is perhaps the 2nd holiest day of the year, after Easter. Since the 20th century, however, Christmas has been secularized by non-Christians and non-practicing Christians.
The holiday, once revered for the birth of Christ, is now viewed by many as a day to realize their materialistic obsessions. It should come as no surprise, that true Christians lament the expunging of Christ from Christmas. After all, during what other December holidays do we erect a tree and decorate it? It is therefore foolish to call such a symbol a holiday tree, when this is a symbol of Christmas. Christian concerns over the secularization of Christmas are indeed misplaced, however. Rather than decry efforts by secularists and atheists to remove “Christmas” from the Christmas season, why not decry the commercialization of Christmas in the first place. Why for example do we exchange gifts on Christmas? Exactly what does this have to do with the birth of Christ? About as much as Easter Eggs and Easter Rabbits have to do with the resurrection of Christ.
The reality is, those who know nothing of Christ, don’t want to be excluded from the season and thus the secularization of Christmas began in earnest with the dawn of the commercial era and the holiday’s religious and spiritual significance was all but lost in the shuffle. For many who “celebrate” (i.e., exchange gifts) during Christmas, Santa Clause (i.e., Saint Nicholas) is far more important than Christ. Gift giving derives from a practice begun by Saint Nicholas (i.e., Sinterklaas) in modern day Turkey, who made a practice of giving gifts to the poor. In honor of Nicholas, a practice began of repeating his accomplishments on December 5th, the date of Nicholas’ death, which somehow came to be associated with Christmas. In some countries, however, these traditions have remained separate, such as in the Netherlands and portions of Germany, where Christmas has retained its religious significance and Dec 5th is a day of gift giving.
Christians therefore should recognize the fact that Christmas has become a secular holiday for non-Christians and would be to surrender “Christmas” and designate another day as the official date to honor the memory and spiritual significance of Christ’s birth. After all, no one knows Christ’s actual birth date, why not choose a time during the year when actual Christians can come together in worship and reverence, not for themselves and not for the purposes of finding sales and/or exchanging gifts, but for the purpose of honoring the man they claim to follow. Most scholars recognize that December 25th was most likely not the date of Christ’s birth, chosen simply by Rome, after the empire embraced Christianity and indeed was probably born in the late summer or early fall. Thus such a move would not be without precident.
Link to article in Atlanta Journal-Constitution
The holiday, once revered for the birth of Christ, is now viewed by many as a day to realize their materialistic obsessions. It should come as no surprise, that true Christians lament the expunging of Christ from Christmas. After all, during what other December holidays do we erect a tree and decorate it? It is therefore foolish to call such a symbol a holiday tree, when this is a symbol of Christmas. Christian concerns over the secularization of Christmas are indeed misplaced, however. Rather than decry efforts by secularists and atheists to remove “Christmas” from the Christmas season, why not decry the commercialization of Christmas in the first place. Why for example do we exchange gifts on Christmas? Exactly what does this have to do with the birth of Christ? About as much as Easter Eggs and Easter Rabbits have to do with the resurrection of Christ.
The reality is, those who know nothing of Christ, don’t want to be excluded from the season and thus the secularization of Christmas began in earnest with the dawn of the commercial era and the holiday’s religious and spiritual significance was all but lost in the shuffle. For many who “celebrate” (i.e., exchange gifts) during Christmas, Santa Clause (i.e., Saint Nicholas) is far more important than Christ. Gift giving derives from a practice begun by Saint Nicholas (i.e., Sinterklaas) in modern day Turkey, who made a practice of giving gifts to the poor. In honor of Nicholas, a practice began of repeating his accomplishments on December 5th, the date of Nicholas’ death, which somehow came to be associated with Christmas. In some countries, however, these traditions have remained separate, such as in the Netherlands and portions of Germany, where Christmas has retained its religious significance and Dec 5th is a day of gift giving.
Christians therefore should recognize the fact that Christmas has become a secular holiday for non-Christians and would be to surrender “Christmas” and designate another day as the official date to honor the memory and spiritual significance of Christ’s birth. After all, no one knows Christ’s actual birth date, why not choose a time during the year when actual Christians can come together in worship and reverence, not for themselves and not for the purposes of finding sales and/or exchanging gifts, but for the purpose of honoring the man they claim to follow. Most scholars recognize that December 25th was most likely not the date of Christ’s birth, chosen simply by Rome, after the empire embraced Christianity and indeed was probably born in the late summer or early fall. Thus such a move would not be without precident.
Link to article in Atlanta Journal-Constitution
About Us
- We are Editor
- Location
- Our profile
About the Phalanx Editor:
Previous posts
- Triumph for "democracy"...Chavez’s supporters win ...
- Germans mix smut and Christianity
- Israel months away from destruction?
- Should a killer be put to death?
- The hidden truth: Iraq did possess WMDs
- Lies my congressman told me
- Jail all child molesters for life….
- BBC says equality lacking in America
- Wal-Mart bad for America?
- Business criticized for not providing free service...
Archives
- October 2005
- November 2005
- December 2005
- January 2006
- February 2006
- March 2006
- April 2006
- May 2006
- June 2006
- July 2006
- August 2006
- September 2006
- October 2006
- November 2006
- December 2006
- January 2007
- February 2007
- March 2007
- April 2007
- May 2007
- June 2007
- July 2007
- August 2007
- September 2007
- October 2007
- November 2007
- December 2007
- January 2008
- February 2008
- March 2008
- April 2008
- May 2008
- June 2008
- July 2008
- August 2008
- September 2008
- October 2008
- November 2008
- December 2008
Links
- Google News
- So what is pulling a Mussolini?
- Why is Johnny so stupid?
- Why is Johnny so poor?
- Why does Johnny vote Democrat?
- The Quotable Phalanx
- JasonPye.com
- The Liberty Papers
- Atlas Blogged
- Adam Smith Institute
- Slow Turning
- My Right Mind
- Reason's Hit and Run
- Adam Smith Institute
- Hammer of Truth
- The Conservative Voice
- The Patriot Act Research Website
- The Drudge Report
- Nealz Nuze
- Cato Institute
- Balanced Politics
- Americans for Fair Tax
- Alliance for School Choice
- My 4 Cents
- Democratic Underground
- MoveOn.org
- National Education Association
- Democratic Party
- Republican Party
- Westboro Baptist Church
- United Nations
- Kyoto Protocol
- Kelo vs. New London
- February 2005
- March 2005
- April 2005
- May 2005
- June 2005
- July 2005
- August 2005
- September 2005
Phalanxian Diatribes:
Other Important links:
Know your enemy (or least those with diametrically opposing points of view):
Earlier Archives:
ATOM 0.3
0 Responses to “Outrage over Christmas misplaced…”
Leave a Reply